I noticed that there has been a flurry of discussion recently about what is known as Modern Monetary Theory (MMT)). It strikes me as a bit half-baked but the proponents of MMT may have a point.
The usual view is that governments collect tax and spend it to pay for their activities. I believe this is exactly the wrong way round. As I understand it, official money is created when government spends it into circulation to cover its expenses. The money must then be withdrawn from circulation through the tax system, so as to complete the cycle and prevent the undue increase in the quantity of money which leads to a general increase in prices as the value of money falls.AN OUTSIDE VIEW
POLITICS ∙ ECONOMICS ∙ RELIGION ∙ MUSIC
fredag 19 juli 2024
A thought about money
torsdag 11 juli 2024
Overdue policies that will probably not happen
- Reform of the Council Tax
- Abolition of Stamp Duty
- Abolition of Capital Gains
- Business Rates to annual assessments and will with fixed equipment, buildings and plant being ignored in the valuation.
onsdag 10 juli 2024
When the wind blows, the trains stop
For the second time this week, trains on many routes in the west of Sweden have been cancelled due to high winds: this happened on Sunday morning (7 July) and again this afternoon (10 July).
Apparently there is a risk of trees falling on the overhead electrification cables, and of the cables themselves getting blown down. The cables come down regularly; a couple of times a week, it is said. I have personally been caught up in two incidents. In the first, the train was stuck in a forest for four hours when the wires came down. This was on a lovely afternoon in July and passengers could enjoy the sun and opportunity to walk their dogs. The stay in the forest was so long because it took two hours to couple a rescue locomotive to the train. A month ago the passengers were ordered off a Copenhagen to Gothenburg train because the wires had been stolen, and that journey ended up with an overnight stay in a hotel.
Which raises two questions. Why are trees allowed to grow where they are an obvious hazard? In steam days the trackside had to be kept clear because of the risk of fires. On electrified lines, the risk of disruption due to trees falling on the track is even greater.
The second is why are the lines electrified at all? Now that electricity is priced on the Europool market, it is not cheap, and there are many lines where there is not enough traffic to justify the cost of putting up the wires and keeping them in order, which is an onerous task in itself.
Perhaps some of this electrification infrastructure should be removed when it is life expired?
tisdag 9 juli 2024
New tri-mode locomotive is exactly wrong
The Stadler class 93 locomotive is a tri mode (diesel/25kV electric/battery) unit intended for both freight and passenger train haulage. Its power is given as 6200 hp on electric traction, 1250 hp on diesel and 540 hp on batteries. Its main purposes is to haul high speed intermodal freight while avoiding diesel running under the wires, with diesel and battery power for the ʻlast mileʼ.
This looks good but is exactly wrong. It is, presumably, a very expensive piece of kit, each one probably costing over £3 million. It that looks like it is brutal on the track - tiny wheels and a 21 ton axle load are a recipe for heavy wear.
Freight trains should not be traveling at high speeds. It wastes energy and damages the track - the modern container carriers with small wheels are track-bashers, and modern passenger trains are also destructive to the point that it is becoming a real problem; the poor state of the track is evident on, for instance, the Great Western Main Line.
Electricity does not come out of the sky. Supplies will have to be enhanced to get rid of diesel running under the wires, and overall thermodynamic efficiency goes down.
The advent of this design points yet again to look at using steam as a benchmark. The 9F freight locomotive delivers over 3000 hp when using coal and about 20% more on diesel fuel. The initial cost of a steam locomotive would probably be a quarter of that of the tri-mode and much the same to run.
As a production locomotive, a new design of three-cylinder 2-8-2 would be a stiff competitor, or another build of the proven 9F class, though the track would have to be modified to allow them back on the national network.
fredag 21 juni 2024
Equal rights for women in Sweden are history
Last Sunday was a Muslim festival, and the Gothenburg city council allowed this to be celebrated with public prayers in Slottskogen, one of the city parks. There was a huge turnout, as the picture shows. How many women can you count?
Who to vote for?
What is this weird lightweight train for?
A thought about money
I noticed that there has been a flurry of discussion recently about what is known as Modern Monetary Theory (MMT)). It strikes me as a bit ...
-
I wrote to my MP on two entirely separate issues recently. The first was to do with the replacement for the Inter City 125 train, which at £...
-
The ultimate net zero lunacy is probably de-carbonising and trying to electrify the entire railway system. In the first place, the railways...
-
The FT has run a couple of pieces on Sweden this week. The first was a report of the outbreak of car burning, the second, today, on the rise...